Jewelry Gifts Under $500

Discover fine jewelry gifts under $500 from Kay. Shop our selection for any occasion.

Necklaces

Rings

Earrings

Bracelets

Yellow Gold

Women's

Men's

167 Results items returned.

Sort By:

Price Low to High
Price High to Low
Newest Arrivals
Most popular

Sort By:

Filter By

Get It Fast

Quick Ship - Ships in 1-3 Business Days (148) Items Available

Store Pickup at

Select Store

Same Day Delivery from Select Store

Get It By Valentine's Day

Get It By Valentine's Day (167) Items Available

Offers & Discounts

10% & up (8) Items Available

20% & up (8) Items Available

30% & up (8) Items Available

Price

$101-$250 (2) Items Available

$251-$500 (165) Items Available

$ min

$ max

Jewelry Type

Earrings (59) Items Available

Necklace (55) Items Available

Bracelet (30) Items Available

Watch (10) Items Available

Ring (9) Items Available

Gender

WOMEN (151) Items Available

MEN (30) Items Available

UNISEX (14) Items Available

Style

3-Stone (3) Items Available

Adjustable (16) Items Available

Animal (16) Items Available

Automatic (3) Items Available

Bar (4) Items Available

Metal Color

Yellow (110) Items Available

White (53) Items Available

Rose (8) Items Available

Black (4) Items Available

Two-Tone (4) Items Available

Metal Type

Gold (78) Items Available

Sterling Silver (40) Items Available

Vermeil (38) Items Available

Stainless Steel (14) Items Available

Gold Plate (1) Items Available

Stone Type

Diamond (17) Items Available

Lab-Grown Diamond (16) Items Available

Alexandrite (1) Items Available

Amethyst (3) Items Available

Aquamarine (1) Items Available

Stone Shape

Round (56) Items Available

Pear (8) Items Available

Emerald (5) Items Available

Heart-Cut (5) Items Available

Oval (4) Items Available

Stone Color

Black (1) Items Available

Blue (17) Items Available

Brown (1) Items Available

Green (9) Items Available

Multi-Color (1) Items Available

Carat Total Weight

Under 1/4 Ctw (29) Items Available

1/4 Ctw - Under 1/2 Ctw (11) Items Available

1/2 Ctw - Under 1 Ctw (4) Items Available

167 Results items returned.

Sort By:

Price Low to High
Price High to Low
Newest Arrivals
Most popular

Sort By:

Variations Available

Unstoppable Love Diamond Necklace 1/10 ct tw Sterling Silver 19"

$299.99

Compare Unstoppable Love Diamond Necklace 1/10 ct tw Sterling Silver 19"

Variations Available

Jaxxon Men's Collection 2.3mm Rope Chain Necklace 18K Yellow Gold-Plated Solid Sterling Silver 22"
New

$399.99

Compare Jaxxon Men's Collection 2.3mm Rope Chain Necklace 18K Yellow Gold-Plated Solid Sterling Silver 22"

Variations Available

Italian Brilliance Diamond-Cut Clover Station Bracelet 14K Yellow Gold 7.5"

$499.99

Compare Italian Brilliance Diamond-Cut Clover Station Bracelet 14K Yellow Gold 7.5"

Variations Available

Diamond-Cut Butterfly Necklace 10K Yellow Gold 18"

$349.99

Compare Diamond-Cut Butterfly Necklace 10K Yellow Gold 18"

Variations Available

Diamond-Cut Oval Twist Hoop Earrings 10K Yellow Gold 30mm

$399.99

Compare Diamond-Cut Oval Twist Hoop Earrings 10K Yellow Gold 30mm

Variations Available

Double Heart Necklace 10K Yellow Gold 18"

$329.99

Compare Double Heart Necklace 10K Yellow Gold 18"

Variations Available

Reaura Love Knot Stud Earrings Repurposed 14K Yellow Gold

$349.99

Compare Reaura Love Knot Stud Earrings Repurposed 14K Yellow Gold

Variations Available

3.5mm Diamond-Cut Rope Chain Bracelet Hollow 10K Yellow Gold 7.5"

$499.99

Compare 3.5mm Diamond-Cut Rope Chain Bracelet Hollow 10K Yellow Gold 7.5"

Variations Available

Flower Outline Station Bracelet 10K Yellow Gold 7.5"

$269.99

Compare Flower Outline Station Bracelet 10K Yellow Gold 7.5"

Variations Available

Men's Diamond-Cut Flat Curb Chain Necklace & Bracelet Gift Set Solid Sterling Silver
Clearance

$349.99

30% off

Was $499.99

Compare Men's Diamond-Cut Flat Curb Chain Necklace & Bracelet Gift Set Solid Sterling Silver

Variations Available

Diamond-Cut Hoop Earrings 14K Yellow Gold 20mm

$429.99

Compare Diamond-Cut Hoop Earrings 14K Yellow Gold 20mm

Variations Available

Multi-Shape White Lab-Created Sapphire Statement Necklace Sterling Silver 18"

$399.99

Compare Multi-Shape White Lab-Created Sapphire Statement Necklace Sterling Silver 18"

Variations Available

Oval Diamond-Cut Hoop Earrings 14K Yellow Gold 25mm

$349.99

Compare Oval Diamond-Cut Hoop Earrings 14K Yellow Gold 25mm

Variations Available

Hidden Message "I Love You" Heart Necklace 10K Yellow Gold 18"

$399.99

Compare Hidden Message "I Love You" Heart Necklace 10K Yellow Gold 18"

Variations Available

"Mama" Script Necklace 10K Yellow Gold 18"

$269.99

Compare "Mama" Script Necklace 10K Yellow Gold 18"

Variations Available

Paperclip Chain Bracelet 5.5mm Hollow 10K Yellow Gold 7.5"

$499.99

Compare Paperclip Chain Bracelet 5.5mm Hollow 10K Yellow Gold 7.5"

Variations Available

Mirror Station Necklace 10K Yellow Gold 18"

$379.99

Compare Mirror Station Necklace 10K Yellow Gold 18"

Variations Available

STUDIO BY KAY Octagon-Cut Lab-Created Emerald Bezel-Set Solitaire Necklace 24K Yellow Gold Vermeil Sterling Silver 18"

$399.99

Compare STUDIO BY KAY Octagon-Cut Lab-Created Emerald Bezel-Set Solitaire Necklace 24K Yellow Gold Vermeil Sterling Silver 18"

Variations Available

Crucifix Necklace 10K Yellow Gold 18"

$329.99

Compare Crucifix Necklace 10K Yellow Gold 18"

Variations Available

Square-Edge Hoop Earrings 14K Yellow Gold 20mm

$299.99

Compare Square-Edge Hoop Earrings 14K Yellow Gold 20mm

Monique Lhuillier Bliss Lab-Grown Diamond Accent Butterfly Necklace 24K Yellow Gold Vermeil Sterling Silver 18"

Variations Available

Monique Lhuillier Bliss Lab-Grown Diamond Accent Butterfly Necklace 24K Yellow Gold Vermeil Sterling Silver 18"

$299.99

Compare Monique Lhuillier Bliss Lab-Grown Diamond Accent Butterfly Necklace 24K Yellow Gold Vermeil Sterling Silver 18"

Variations Available

Bead Station Mirror Chain Necklace Hollow 10K Yellow Gold 18"
Clearance

$244.99

30% off

Was $349.99

Compare Bead Station Mirror Chain Necklace Hollow 10K Yellow Gold 18"

Variations Available

STUDIO BY KAY Baguette, Pear & Round-Cut Lab-Created Emerald Bracelet 24K Yellow Gold Vermeil Sterling Silver 7.25"

$499.99

Compare STUDIO BY KAY Baguette, Pear & Round-Cut Lab-Created Emerald Bracelet 24K Yellow Gold Vermeil Sterling Silver 7.25"

Variations Available

STUDIO BY KAY Lab-Created Opal Tennis Bracelet Sterling Silver 7.25"

$399.99

Compare STUDIO BY KAY Lab-Created Opal Tennis Bracelet Sterling Silver 7.25"

Variations Available

Heart Anklet 10K Yellow Gold 10"

$379.99

Compare Heart Anklet 10K Yellow Gold 10"

Variations Available

STUDIO BY KAY Blue Lab-Created Sapphire Link Necklace 24K Yellow Gold Vermeil Sterling Silver 18"

$299.99

Compare STUDIO BY KAY Blue Lab-Created Sapphire Link Necklace 24K Yellow Gold Vermeil Sterling Silver 18"

Variations Available

Open Heart Dangle Station Necklace 10K Yellow Gold 18"
Clearance

$244.99

30% off

Was $349.99

Compare Open Heart Dangle Station Necklace 10K Yellow Gold 18"

Variations Available

Heart & Key Charm Necklace 14K Yellow Gold 18"

$449.99

Compare Heart & Key Charm Necklace 14K Yellow Gold 18"

Variations Available

STUDIO BY KAY Cultured Pearl, Swiss Blue Topaz & White Lab-Created Sapphire Drop Earrings 24K Yellow Gold Vermeil Sterling Silver
Clearance

$279.99

30% off

Was $399.99

Compare STUDIO BY KAY Cultured Pearl, Swiss Blue Topaz & White Lab-Created Sapphire Drop Earrings 24K Yellow Gold Vermeil Sterling Silver

Variations Available

Twist & Polished Hoop Earrings Set 10K Yellow Gold
Clearance

$293.99

30% off

Was $419.99

Compare Twist & Polished Hoop Earrings Set 10K Yellow Gold

Variations Available

STUDIO BY KAY Emerald-Cut Swiss Blue Topaz & White Lab-Created Sapphire Bracelet 24K Yellow Gold Vermeil Sterling Silver 7.25"

$399.99

Compare STUDIO BY KAY Emerald-Cut Swiss Blue Topaz & White Lab-Created Sapphire Bracelet 24K Yellow Gold Vermeil Sterling Silver 7.25"

Variations Available

STUDIO BY KAY Oval-Cut Lab-Created Emerald Huggie Hoop Earrings 24K Yellow Gold Vermeil Sterling Silver

$399.99

Compare STUDIO BY KAY Oval-Cut Lab-Created Emerald Huggie Hoop Earrings 24K Yellow Gold Vermeil Sterling Silver

Variations Available

Disney Treasures The Nightmare Before Christmas Oval-Cut Black Onyx & Diamond Wave Ring 1/6 ct tw Black Rhodium-Plated Sterling Silver

$299.99

Compare Disney Treasures The Nightmare Before Christmas Oval-Cut Black Onyx & Diamond Wave Ring 1/6 ct tw Black Rhodium-Plated Sterling Silver

Variations Available

KAY Lab-Grown Diamonds Cultured Pearl Scatter Ring 1/10 ct tw 10K Yellow Gold

$449.99

Compare KAY Lab-Grown Diamonds Cultured Pearl Scatter Ring 1/10 ct tw 10K Yellow Gold

Monique Lhuillier Bliss Lab-Grown Diamond Accent Butterfly Stud Earrings 24K Yellow Gold Vermeil Sterling Silver

Variations Available

Monique Lhuillier Bliss Lab-Grown Diamond Accent Butterfly Stud Earrings 24K Yellow Gold Vermeil Sterling Silver

$299.99

Compare Monique Lhuillier Bliss Lab-Grown Diamond Accent Butterfly Stud Earrings 24K Yellow Gold Vermeil Sterling Silver

Variations Available

Dorica Chain Anklet Solid 10K Yellow Gold 10"

$399.99

Compare Dorica Chain Anklet Solid 10K Yellow Gold 10"

Variations Available

Cultured Pearl & White Lab-Created Sapphire Twist Cuff Bangle Bracelet Sterling Silver 6.75"

$399.99

Compare Cultured Pearl & White Lab-Created Sapphire Twist Cuff Bangle Bracelet Sterling Silver 6.75"

Variations Available

STUDIO BY KAY Blue Lab-Created Sapphire Link Ring 24K Yellow Gold Vermeil Sterling Silver

$299.99

Compare STUDIO BY KAY Blue Lab-Created Sapphire Link Ring 24K Yellow Gold Vermeil Sterling Silver

Variations Available

STUDIO BY KAY Capsule-Shaped Amethyst Necklace 24K Yellow Gold Vermeil Sterling Silver 18"

$349.99

Compare STUDIO BY KAY Capsule-Shaped Amethyst Necklace 24K Yellow Gold Vermeil Sterling Silver 18"

Variations Available

Flat Hoop Earrings 10K Yellow Gold 15mm

$379.99

Compare Flat Hoop Earrings 10K Yellow Gold 15mm

Variations Available

Diamond-Cut Screw Hoop Earrings 10K Yellow Gold 15mm

$499.99

Compare Diamond-Cut Screw Hoop Earrings 10K Yellow Gold 15mm

Variations Available

STUDIO BY KAY Heart-Shaped Lab-Created Ruby Line Bracelet Sterling Silver 7.25"

$399.99

Compare STUDIO BY KAY Heart-Shaped Lab-Created Ruby Line Bracelet Sterling Silver 7.25"

Showing 42 of 167 products

Jewelry Gifts Under $500

Filter By

Get It Fast

Get It By Valentine's Day

Offers & Discounts

Price

Jewelry Type

Gender

Style

Metal Color

Metal Type

Stone Type

Stone Shape

Stone Color

Carat Total Weight

Jaxxon Men's Collection 2.3mm Rope Chain Necklace 18K Yellow Gold-Plated Solid Sterling Silver 22"New

Men's Diamond-Cut Flat Curb Chain Necklace & Bracelet Gift Set Solid Sterling SilverClearance

Bead Station Mirror Chain Necklace Hollow 10K Yellow Gold 18"Clearance

Open Heart Dangle Station Necklace 10K Yellow Gold 18"Clearance

STUDIO BY KAY Cultured Pearl, Swiss Blue Topaz & White Lab-Created Sapphire Drop Earrings 24K Yellow Gold Vermeil Sterling SilverClearance

Twist & Polished Hoop Earrings Set 10K Yellow GoldClearance

CUSTOMER SERVICES

PAYMENTS & REWARDS

STORES & SERVICES

ABOUT US

QUICK LINKS & EDUCATION

FOLLOW US

Jaxxon Men's Collection 2.3mm Rope Chain Necklace 18K Yellow Gold-Plated Solid Sterling Silver 22"
New

Men's Diamond-Cut Flat Curb Chain Necklace & Bracelet Gift Set Solid Sterling Silver
Clearance

Bead Station Mirror Chain Necklace Hollow 10K Yellow Gold 18"
Clearance

Open Heart Dangle Station Necklace 10K Yellow Gold 18"
Clearance

STUDIO BY KAY Cultured Pearl, Swiss Blue Topaz & White Lab-Created Sapphire Drop Earrings 24K Yellow Gold Vermeil Sterling Silver
Clearance

Twist & Polished Hoop Earrings Set 10K Yellow Gold
Clearance