Skip to Content Skip to Navigation Skip to Offers

Previously Owned Jewelry

1052 Results items returned.
 Store Pickup at Select Store
1052 Results items returned.
Previously Owned Diamond Engagement Ring Setting 1/2 ct tw Pear-shaped 14K White Gold

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$329.99 
70% off
Was $1,099.98 
Previously Owned Adrianna Papell Round-Cut Diamond Bridal Set 2-3/8 ct tw 14K White Gold Size 5

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$4,249.99 
50% off
Was $8,499.98 
Previously Owned Ring 1-1/2 ct tw Diamonds 14K White Gold

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$1,279.60 
60% off
Was $3,199.00 
Previously Owned Diamond Wedding Band 1 ct tw 14K White Gold

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$1,439.40 
40% off
Was $2,399.00 
Previously Owned Diamond Band 1/4 ct tw Round-cut 10K White Gold

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$419.99 
40% off
Was $699.99 
Previously Owned Neil Lane Wedding Band 1/6 ct tw Round-cut Diamonds 14K White Gold

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$329.99 
70% off
Was $1,099.99 
Previously Owned Black/White Diamond Engagement Ring 3/4 ct tw 14K Gold

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$999.99 
50% off
Was $1,999.99 
Previously Owned Citizen Silhouette Crystal Women's Watch FE1230-51X

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$211.25 
35% off
Was $325.00 
Previously Owned Diamond Earrings 3/8 ct tw Round-cut 10K Rose Gold

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$539.99 
40% off
Was $899.99 
Previously Owned Neil Lane Artistry Oval-Cut Lab-Grown Diamond Engagement Ring 2-1/2 ct tw 14K Yellow Gold

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$3,179.99 
40% off
Was $5,299.99 
Previously Owned Diamond Anniversary Ring 1/3 ct tw Round-cut 10K White Gold

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$599.99 
40% off
Was $999.99 
Previously Owned Ring 1/2 ct tw Diamonds 14K White Gold

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$519.60 
60% off
Was $1,299.00 
Previously Owned Men's THE LEO Diamond Wedding Band 1 ct tw Round-cut 14K White Gold

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$2,699.99 
40% off
Was $4,499.99 
Previously Owned Round-Cut Diamond Three-Stone Bridal Set 2-3/8 ct tw 14K White Gold Size 4.75

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$3,699.49 
50% off
Was $7,398.99 
Previously Owned THE LEO Legacy Lab-Grown Diamond Engagement Ring 3-1/2 ct tw 14K White Gold

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$5,459.99 
40% off
Was $9,099.99 
Previously Owned Certified Princess-Cut Diamond Solitaire Engagement Ring 3/4 ct tw 14K White Gold & Platinum (F/I1)

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$1,359.60 
60% off
Was $3,399.00 
Previously Owned Pear-Shaped Opal & Diamond Ring 1/10 ct tw 10K Rose Gold

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$419.99 
40% off
Was $699.99 
Previously Owned Every Moment Diamond Crossover Infinity Band 1 ct tw 14K White Gold

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$1,119.99 
60% off
Was $2,799.99 
Previously Owned KAY Lab-Grown Diamonds Ring 2 ct tw 14K White Gold

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$1,379.99 
40% off
Was $2,299.99 
Previously Owned Diamond Wedding Band 1/2 ct tw Round-cut 14K Yellow Gold

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$557.40 
40% off
Was $929.00 
Previously Owned Neil Lane Engagement Ring 2-3/4 ct tw Round-cut Diamonds 14K White Gold

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$7,799.50 
50% off
Was $15,599.00 
Previously Owned Certified Round-Cut Diamond Solitaire Stud Earrings 1/2 ct tw 14K Yellow Gold (I/I1)

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$881.30 
30% off
Was $1,259.00 
Previously Owned KAY Lab-Grown Diamonds Bypass Ring 1/2 ct tw 14K White Gold

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$499.99 
50% off
Was $999.99 
Previously Owned Radiant Reflections 1/2 ct tw Diamonds 10K White Gold Soliatire Earrings (J/I3)

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$615.30 
30% off
Was $879.00 
undefinedundefinedundefined
Previously Owned Le Vian Diamond Anniversary Ring 1 ct tw 14K Honey Gold

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$1,649.99 
50% off
Was $3,299.99 
Previously Owned THE LEO Artisan Diamond Princess-Cut Solitaire Engagement Ring 1/2 ct tw 14K White Gold & Platinum (I/SI2)

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$1,339.60 
60% off
Was $3,349.00 
Previously Owned Diamond Engagement Ring 3/4 ct tw Round-cut 14K Rose Gold

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$1,099.99 
50% off
Was $2,199.99 
Previously Owned Lab-Grown Diamonds Oval-Shaped Engagement Ring 5 ct tw 14K White Gold

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$2,999.99 
70% off
Was $9,999.99 
Previously Owned Neil Lane Artistry Oval-Cut Lab-Grown Diamond Engagement Ring 4 ct tw 14K White Gold

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$4,549.99 
50% off
Was $9,099.99 
Previously Owned Diamond Ring 1 ct Round-cut 10K White Gold

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$599.99 
60% off
Was $1,499.99 
Previously Owned Citizen Ceci Women's Watch EM1163-09X

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$276.25 
35% off
Was $425.00 
Previously Owned Diamond Bypass Cluster Ring 1/3 ct tw Round-cut 10K Yellow Gold

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$399.99 
50% off
Was $799.99 
Previously Owned Round-Cut Diamond Three-Stone Bridal Set 2 ct tw 14K Two-Tone Gold Size 6.25

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$2,498.50 
50% off
Was $4,997.00 
Previously Owned Round-Cut Diamond Cushion Halo Bridal Set 1-5/8 ct tw 10K White Gold Size 6

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$2,964.49 
50% off
Was $5,928.99 
Previously Owned Encircled by Love Diamond Ring 1/3 ct tw Round-cut 10K White Gold

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$499.99 
50% off
Was $999.99 
Previously Owned Neil Lane Men's Diamond Wedding Band 1/5 ct tw 14K Yellow Gold

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$1,499.99 
40% off
Was $2,499.99 
Previously Owned KAY Lab-Grown Diamonds Solitaire Stud Earrings 3/4 ct tw 14K White Gold (F/SI2)

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$790.30 
30% off
Was $1,129.00 
Previously Owned Neil Lane Diamond Wedding Band 1/4 ct tw Round-Cut 14K Yellow Gold

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$479.99 
60% off
Was $1,199.99 
Previously Owned Diamond Ring 1-1/2 ct tw Round 14K White Gold

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$1,199.99 
40% off
Was $1,999.99 
Previously Owned THE LEO Wedding Band 1/4 ct tw Diamonds 14K White Gold

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$599.99 
40% off
Was $999.99 
undefinedundefinedundefined
Previously Owned Monique Lhuillier Bliss Diamond Engagement Ring 1-1/3 ct tw Round-cut 18K White Gold

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$3,599.99 
70% off
Was $11,999.99 
Previously Owned Citizen Silhouette Crystal Watch Boxed Set FE1234-50D

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$308.75 
35% off
Was $475.00 
Showing 42 of 1052 products
Find previously owned jewelry at affordable prices when you shop at KAY. Still in impeccable condition, you can purchase pre-owned engagement rings, pre-owned diamond rings, and more without the strain on your bank account. Explore our selection online or at a KAY near you to find the perfect piece at the perfect price.