Skip to Content Skip to Navigation Skip to Offers

Affordable Valentine's Day Gifts $250 to $500

Style meets affordable with these Valentine's Day Jewelry Gifts under $500
75 Results items returned.
75 Results items returned.
Natural Oval-Cut Ruby & Diamond Accent Tilted Heart Necklace 10K Yellow Gold 18"

Clearance

$314.99 
30% off
Was $449.99 
Hidden Message "I Love You" Heart Necklace 10K Yellow Gold 18"

$399.99 
undefinedundefinedundefined
Diamond Accent Tilted Hearts Necklace 10K Rose Gold 18"

$399.99 
undefinedundefinedundefined
Double Heart Necklace 10K Yellow Gold 18"

$329.99 
undefinedundefinedundefined
Heart-Shaped Lab-Created Opal & Lab-Created Ruby Tennis Bracelet Sterling Silver 7.5"

Clearance

$299.99 
25% off
Was $399.99 
Couple's Raised Initials Heart Ring with White Lab-Created Sapphires (2 Initials)

Personalized

$255.06 
undefinedundefinedundefined
STUDIO BY KAY Diamond Paperclip Link Earrings 1/5 ct tw 24K Yellow Gold Vermeil Sterling Silver

Clearance

$349.99 
30% off
Was $499.99 
Cultured Pearl & Diamond Ring 1/10 ct tw 10K Yellow Gold

$499.99 
undefinedundefinedundefined
Unstoppable Love Diamond Necklace 1/10 ct tw Sterling Silver 19"

$299.99 
Diamond Cushion Halo Promise Ring 1/10 ct tw Sterling Silver

Online Exclusive

$349.99 
undefinedundefinedundefined
Amethyst & Diamond Heart Necklace 1/4 ct tw Sterling Silver & 10K Yellow Gold 18"

Clearance

$349.99 
30% off
Was $499.99 
undefinedundefinedundefined
1/10 ct tw Diamond and Birthstone Round Disc Charm Necklace (1 Stone and Initial)

Personalized

$254.97 
undefinedundefinedundefined
Cultured Pearl & White Lab-Created Sapphire Fashion Ring 10K Yellow Gold

Online Exclusive

$449.99 
Cultured Pearl Paperclip Necklace Sterling Silver 18"

Online Exclusive

$299.99 
undefinedundefinedundefined
STUDIO BY KAY Multi-Diamond Chain Link Necklace 1/3 ct tw 24K Yellow Gold Vermeil Sterling Silver 18"

Clearance

$349.99 
30% off
Was $499.99 
Cultured Pearl Swirl Ring 10K Yellow Gold

Online Exclusive

$299.99 
Cultured Pearl & Diamond Necklace 1/20 ct tw 10K Yellow Gold

$499.99 
undefinedundefinedundefined
Multi-Diamond Pear-Shaped Halo Promise Ring 1/10 ct tw Sterling Silver

Online Exclusive

$349.99 
undefinedundefinedundefined
Freshwater Cultured Pearl Station Necklace 10K Yellow Gold 18"

$399.99 
Multi-Diamond Halo Promise Ring 1/4 ct tw 10K White Gold

Clearance

$419.99 
40% off
Was $699.99 
undefinedundefinedundefined
Men's Diamond Cross Necklace 1/6 ct tw Stainless Steel with Black Ion Plate 22"

$469.99 
undefinedundefinedundefined
Blue & White Lab-Created Sapphire Bracelet Sterling Silver & Titanium

Clearance

$279.99 
30% off
Was $399.99 
undefinedundefinedundefined
Heart-Shaped Amethyst & Diamond Bracelet 1/8 ct tw Sterling Silver 7.25"

Clearance

$279.99 
30% off
Was $399.99 
Diamond Heart & Infinity Symbol Open Fashion Ring 1/10 ct tw 10K Yellow Gold

Online Exclusive

$499.99 
undefinedundefinedundefined
STUDIO BY KAY Diamond Pavé Ring 1/4 ct tw 10K Yellow Gold

Clearance

$489.99 
30% off
Was $699.99 
Ink & Ice Men's Square-Cut Black Onyx & Black Diamond Barbed Wire Ring 1/10 ct tw Black Rhodium-Plated Sterling Silver

$499.99 
undefinedundefinedundefined
KAY Lab-Grown Diamonds Pear-Shaped & Round-Cut Diamond Two-Stone Contour Fashion Ring 1/5 ct tw 10K Yellow Gold

Clearance

$489.99 
30% off
Was $699.99 
Lab-Created Ruby & White Lab-Created Sapphire Lock Toggle Paperclip Necklace Sterling Silver 18"

New

$349.99 
Cultured Pearl, Lab-Created Ruby & White Lab-Created Sapphire Spiritual Symbols Paperclip Charm Necklace Sterling Silver 18"

New

$449.99 
Lab-Created Ruby, Pink & White Lab-Created Sapphire Charms Paperclip Chain Necklace Sterling Silver 18"

New

$449.99 
Cultured Pearl, Heart-Shaped Lab-Created Ruby & White Lab-Created Sapphire Drop Earrings 10K Yellow Gold

New

$399.99 
STUDIO BY KAY Multi-Diamond Link Ring 1/3 ct tw 24K Yellow Gold Vermeil Sterling Silver

$499.99 
undefinedundefinedundefined
STUDIO BY KAY Diamond Split-Shank Ring 1/20 ct tw 10K Yellow Gold

Clearance

$419.99 
30% off
Was $599.99 
undefinedundefinedundefined
STUDIO BY KAY Multi-Diamond Hoop Earrings 1/4 ct tw 24K Yellow Gold Vermeil Sterling Silver

Clearance

$314.99 
30% off
Was $449.99 
undefinedundefinedundefined
STUDIO BY KAY Multi-Diamond Chain Link Cuff Bangle Bracelet 1/3 ct tw 24K Gold Vermeil Sterling Silver

Clearance

$489.99 
30% off
Was $699.99 
undefinedundefinedundefined
Paperclip Chain Toggle Bracelet Semi-Solid Sterling Silver 8"

Clearance

$257.99 
40% off
Was $429.99 
Handwriting Engravable Heart Disc with Rope Edge Necklace Sterling Silver

Personalized

$349.99 
undefinedundefinedundefined
Lab-Created Ruby & Diamond Double Heart Necklace 1/5 ct tw Sterling Silver & 10K Yellow Gold 18"

Clearance

$314.99 
30% off
Was $449.99 
undefinedundefinedundefined
STUDIO BY KAY Multi-Diamond Chain Link J-Hoop Earrings 1/3 ct tw 24K Yellow Gold Vermeil Sterling Silver

Clearance

$419.99 
30% off
Was $599.99 
undefinedundefinedundefined
STUDIO BY KAY Diamond Deconstructed Open Ring 1/5 ct tw 10K Yellow Gold

Clearance

$349.99 
30% off
Was $499.99 
Cultured Pearl & White Lab-Created Sapphire Heart Necklace Sterling Silver 18"

New

$429.99 
undefinedundefinedundefined
Oval-Cut Amethyst Solitaire Bezel-Set Signet Ring 10K Yellow Gold

Clearance

$359.99 
40% off
Was $599.99 
Showing 42 of 75 products