Skip to Content Skip to Navigation
Love doesn't have to wait—shop early for your Valentine!

Loose Amethyst gemstone. Shop amethyst engagement rings from Kay.

AMETHYST
Aquamarine gemstone. Shop aquamarine engagement rings from Kay

AQUAMARINE
Blue topaz gemstone. Shop blue topaz engagement rings from Kay.

BLUE TOPAZ
Citrine gemstone. Shop citrine engagement rings from Kay.

CITRINE
Emerald gemstone. Shop emerald gemstone engagement rings from Kay.

EMERALD
Garnet gemstone. Shop garnet engagement rings at Kay.

GARNET
Morganite gemstone. Shop morganite engagement rings at Kay Jewelers.

MORGANITE
Opal gemstone. Shop opal engagement rings from Kay.

OPAL
Loose white pearl. Shop pearl engagement rings at Kay Jewelers

PEARL
Peridot gemstone. Shop peridot engagement rings from Kay

PERIDOT
Ruby gemstone. Shop ruby engagement rings from Kay

RUBY
Blue sapphire gemstone. Shop sapphire engagement rings from Kay.

SAPPHIRE
Tanzanite gemstone. Shop tanzanite engagement rings from Kay Jewelers.

TANZANITE
Loose yellow diamond. Shop yellow diamond engagement rings from Kay

YELLOW DIAMOND

Gemstone Engagement Rings

Shop KAY’s online collection of gemstone engagement rings and find a unique ring as beautiful and vibrant as she is. Explore colorful gemstone center stones and side stones that truly represent her personal style. Learn more about gemstone engagement rings.

Select Refinements

Clear Filters
See Results (153)