Skip to Content Skip to Navigation Skip to Offers

Gemstone Engagement Ring Styles

Add color and personality with gemstone engagement ring styles that go beyond the traditional diamond. Choose by birthstone or color for one-of-a-kind style.
132 Results items returned.
 Store Pick Up at Select Store
132 Results items returned.
undefinedundefinedundefined
White Lab-Created Sapphire Ring Sterling Silver
+7 more

Sale

$107.99 
40% off
Was $179.99 
undefinedundefinedundefined
Disney Treasures The Nightmare Before Christmas Oval-Cut Black Onyx & Diamond Ring 1/5 ct tw Sterling Silver

$244.99 
30% off
Was $349.99 
undefinedundefinedundefined
Lab-Created Ruby Ring 1/10 ct tw Diamonds Sterling Silver

Online Exclusive

$139.99 
30% off
Was $199.99 
Now + Forever Oval-Cut Amethyst & Diamond Engagement Ring 1/5 ct tw 14K Yellow Gold

Online Exclusive

$999.99 
undefinedundefinedundefined
Now + Forever Pear-Shaped Light Amethyst & Round-Cut Diamond Twist Shank Engagement Ring 3/8 ct tw 14K Rose Gold Size 7

$1,999.99 
Now + Forever Oval-Cut London Blue Topaz & Diamond Halo Engagement Ring 1/3 ct tw 14K Rose Gold

Online Exclusive

$1,499.99 
Neil Lane Pear-Shaped Green Quartz & Diamond Halo Engagement Ring 3/8 ct tw 14K White Gold

$2,299.99 
Neil Lane Cushion-Cut London Blue Topaz Engagement Ring 1/2 ct tw Diamond 14K White Gold

$1,999.99 
undefinedundefinedundefined
Now + Forever Aquamarine & Lab-Created Sapphire Engagement Ring Round-cut 14K White Gold

$1,199.99 
Now + Forever Amethyst & Diamond Engagement Ring 1/2 ct tw Pear & Round-cut 10K Rose Gold

Online Exclusive

$1,799.99 
Neil Lane Princess-Cut Diamond & Natural Ruby Three-Stone Engagement Ring 3/4 ct tw 14K White Gold

$3,299.99 
Neil Lane Oval-cut Tanzanite Bridal Set 1/2 ct tw Diamonds 14K White Gold

$3,999.98 
Memories Moments Magic Oval-Cut Diamond & Pear-Shaped Blue Sapphire Three-Stone Engagement Ring 3/4 ct tw 14K White Gold

Online Exclusive

$3,999.99 
Neil Lane Pear-Shaped London Blue Topaz, Diamond & Cultured Akoya Pearl Engagement Ring 1/5 ct tw 14K White Gold

$1,699.99 
Neil Lane Pear-Shaped Diamond & Natural Blue-Sapphire Bridal Set 1 ct tw 14K White Gold

$5,299.98 
Neil Lane Oval-Cut Natural Ruby & Diamond Engagement Ring 1/2 ct tw 14K White Gold

$4,999.99 
Now + Forever Octagon-Cut London Blue Topaz & Diamond Double Halo Engagement Ring 7/8 ct tw 14K Yellow Gold

Online Exclusive

$3,499.99 
Now + Forever Round-Cut Diamond & Natural Blue Sapphire Bypass Engagement Ring 3/4 ct tw 14K White Gold

Online Exclusive

$4,299.99 
Neil Lane Morganite Engagement Ring 3/4 ct tw Pear & Round-cut 14K White Gold

Online Exclusive

$3,499.99 
Neil Lane Morganite & Diamond Engagement Ring 1/2 ct tw Round-cut 14K Rose Gold

$2,499.99 
Now + Forever Amethyst & Diamond Engagement Ring 1/5 ct tw Oval & Round-cut 10K Rose Gold

Online Exclusive

$1,599.99 
Neil Lane Sapphire Engagement Ring 1/2 ct tw Diamonds 14K Gold

Online Exclusive

$4,499.99 
Neil Lane Radiant-Cut Green Quartz & Diamond Halo Engagement Ring 5/8 ct tw 14K Two-Tone Gold
Variations Available

$2,499.99 
Neil Lane Morganite & Diamond Engagement Ring 3/4 ct tw Cushion, Pear & Round-cut 14K Rose Gold

$3,499.99 
Neil Lane Emerald-Cut Natural Emerald & Diamond Bridal Set 5/8 ct tw 14K White Gold

$5,299.98 
Neil Lane Cushion-cut Morganite Bridal Set 1 ct tw Diamonds 14K Rose Gold

$5,199.98 
Neil Lane Square Emerald-Cut Green Quartz Engagement Ring 3/8 ct tw Diamond 14K White Gold

$2,499.99 
Memories Moments Magic Round-Cut Diamond & Blue Sapphire Three-Stone Engagement Ring 5/8 ct tw 14K White Gold

Online Exclusive

$2,799.99 
Neil Lane Aquamarine & Diamond Engagement Ring 5/8 ct tw Round-cut 14K White Gold

$3,499.99 
Neil Lane Cushion-Cut London Blue Topaz & Round-Cut Diamond Bridal Set 7/8 ct tw 14K White Gold

$3,699.98 
Now + Forever Blue Topaz Engagement Ring 1/4 ct tw Diamonds 14K White Gold

Online Exclusive

$1,999.99 
Neil Lane Oval-Cut Green Quartz Bridal Set 7/8 ct tw Diamond 14K White Gold

$4,299.98 
Neil Lane Radiant-Cut Amethyst & Diamond Halo Bridal Set 5/8 ct tw 14K White Gold

$3,999.98 
Limor Touchstone Swiss Blue Topaz & Diamond Engagement Ring 1/2 ct tw 14K White Gold

New

$2,499.99 
Neil Lane Pear Shaped-cut Garnet and Diamond Bridal Set 1/2 ct tw 14K Rose Gold

$3,699.98 
Now + Forever Aquamarine Engagement Ring 5/8 ct tw Diamonds 14K White Gold

Online Exclusive

$1,999.99 
Now + Forever Round-Cut Diamond & Natural Blue Sapphire Trios Engagement Ring 3/4 ct tw 14K Yellow Gold

Online Exclusive

$3,799.99 
Limor Touchstone Oval-Cut Morganite & Diamond Engagement Ring 3/4 ct tw 14K Rose Gold

New

$2,999.99 
Limor Touchstone Square-Cut Green Quartz & Diamond Engagement Ring 5/8 ct tw 14K White Gold

New

$2,799.99 
Limor Touchstone Oval-Cut Swiss Blue Topaz & Diamond Halo Engagement Ring 3/8 ct tw 14K White Gold

New

$2,199.99 
Le Vian Emerald Ring 1/5 ct tw Diamonds 14K Honey Gold

$1,999.99 
Now + Forever Amethyst Engagement Ring 3/8 ct tw Diamonds 14K Yellow Gold

$1,499.99 
Showing 42 of 132 products

Gemstone engagement rings are both unique and colorful. Wear the story of your love with gemstone engagement rings from Kay, whether it’s your partners birthstone or favorite color a gemstone engagement ring will a beautiful choice. Kay has a wide range of styles to choose from to find your partner the ring of their dreams. Make today the day you say yes to the ring!  Learn more.