Skip to Content Skip to Navigation Skip to Offers

Unique Engagement Rings

Bold engagement rings are different from your typical engagement ring, with unique shapes, gemstones and more you'll find the perfect style ring your partner will love. Wear the story of your love with engagement rings from Kay. Say yes to Kay's collection of unique engagement rings in stunning styles.

89 Results items returned.
 Store Pick Up at Select Store
89 Results items returned.
undefinedundefinedundefined
Neil Lane Morganite Engagement Ring 3/4 ct tw Pear & Round-cut 14K Rose Gold

Sale - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$1,999.99 
43% off
Was $3,499.99 
undefinedundefinedundefined
Neil Lane Heart-Shaped Black Diamond & White Diamond Engagement Ring 1-1/2 ct tw 14K Rose Gold

Sale - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$1,799.99 
40% off
Was $2,999.99 
Now + Forever Oval-Cut Amethyst & Diamond Engagement Ring 1/5 ct tw 14K Rose Gold

GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$699.99 
30% off
Was $999.99 
Now + Forever Diamond Engagement Ring 1/4 ct tw Round-cut 10K Yellow Gold

Online Exclusive - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$559.99 
30% off
Was $799.99 
Previously Owned Diamond Engagement Ring 2 ct tw Princess & Round-cut 14K White Gold

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$2,279.99 
40% off
Was $3,799.99 
Neil Lane Rhodolite Garnet & Diamond Engagement Ring 1/2 ct tw Round-cut 14K White Gold

Clearance - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$1,249.99 
50% off
Was $2,499.99 
Now + Forever Pear-Shaped Light Amethyst & Round-Cut Diamond Twist Shank Engagement Ring 3/8 ct tw 14K Rose Gold Size 7

GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$1,399.99 
30% off
Was $1,999.99 
Toi et Moi Emerald-Cut & Pear-Shaped Lab-Grown diamond Engagement ring 4-1/4 ct tw 14K White Gold

Clearance - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$6,419.99 
40% off
Was $10,699.99 
undefinedundefinedundefined
Now + Forever Round-Cut Diamond Engagement Ring 7/8 ct tw 14K Rose Gold

GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$2,309.99 
30% off
Was $3,299.99 
Neil Lane Morganite & Diamond Engagement Ring 1/3 ct tw Round-cut 14K Rose Gold

Clearance - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$1,259.99 
40% off
Was $2,099.99 
Neil Lane Pear-Shaped Diamond Engagement Ring 1-7/8 ct tw 14K White Gold

Clearance - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$3,349.99 
50% off
Was $6,699.99 
Neil Lane Radiant-cut Aquamarine Engagement Ring 1/2 ct tw Diamonds 14K White Gold

Clearance - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$1,739.99 
40% off
Was $2,899.99 
Previously Owned THE LEO First Light Diamond Princess-Cut Engagement Ring 3/4 ct tw 14K Two-Tone Gold

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$1,799.99 
40% off
Was $2,999.99 
Previously Owned THE LEO First Light Diamond Engagement Ring 1 ct tw Oval & Round-cut 14K White Gold

Previously Owned Lovingly Restored - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$2,939.99 
40% off
Was $4,899.99 
Neil Lane Round Diamond Engagement Ring 1/2 ct tw 14K White Gold

Online Exclusive - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$1,749.99 
30% off
Was $2,499.99 
Now + Forever Emerald-Cut London Blue Topaz & Diamond Engagement Ring 7/8 ct tw 14K White Gold

GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$2,449.99 
30% off
Was $3,499.99 
Toi et Moi Pear-Shaped & Oval-Cut Lab-Grown Diamond Engagement ring 2 ct tw in 14K Yellow Gold
Variations Available

Clearance - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$2,399.99 
40% off
Was $3,999.99 
Now + Forever Diamond Engagement Ring 3 ct tw Round & Baguette 14K White Gold

GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$4,339.99 
30% off
Was $6,199.99 
Now + Forever Princess-Cut Black Diamond & White Diamond Halo Engagement Ring 1-1/5 ct tw 14K White Gold

Online Exclusive

$2,099.99 
30% off
Was $2,999.99 
Toi et Moi Emerald-Cut & Pear-Shaped Lab-Grown diamond Engagement Ring 4-1/4 ct tw 14K Rose Gold

Online Exclusive - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$7,489.99 
30% off
Was $10,699.99 
Neil Lane Oval-Cut Green Quartz Engagement Ring 3/4 ct tw Diamond 14K White Gold

GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$2,099.99 
30% off
Was $2,999.99 
Neil Lane Pear-Shaped Diamond Engagement Ring 1-1/8 ct tw 14K White Gold

Online Exclusive - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$3,849.99 
30% off
Was $5,499.99 
undefinedundefinedundefined
Neil Lane Pear-Shaped Black & White Diamond Engagement Ring 1-1/8 ct tw 14K Yellow Gold

Clearance - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$2,024.99 
25% off
Was $2,699.99 
Now + Forever Multi-Diamond Center Bridal Set 7/8 ct tw Baguette & Round-cut 10K White Gold

Online Exclusive - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$1,714.99 
30% off
Was $2,449.99 
Neil Lane Morganite & Diamond Engagement Ring 1/2 ct tw Round-cut 14K Rose Gold

GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$1,749.99 
30% off
Was $2,499.99 
Neil Lane Engagement Ring 3/4 ct tw Diamonds 14K White Gold

Online Exclusive - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$2,099.99 
30% off
Was $2,999.99 
Now + Forever Round-Cut Diamond Celtic Love Knot Shank Engagement Ring 1/2 ct tw 14K Rose Gold

Online Exclusive - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$1,679.99 
30% off
Was $2,399.99 
Neil Lane Black & White Diamond Engagement Ring 1-3/8 ct tw Princess & Round-cut 14K Rose Gold

Clearance - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$1,079.99 
60% off
Was $2,699.99 
undefinedundefinedundefined
Now + Forever Multi-Diamond Center Bridal Set 1-1/2 ct tw Round & Baguette-cut 10K White Gold

Clearance - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$2,379.99 
30% off
Was $3,399.99 
Neil Lane Oval-Cut Morganite & Diamond Engagement Ring 1/2 ct tw 14K Rose Gold

Clearance - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$1,199.99 
60% off
Was $2,999.99 
Neil Lane Aquamarine & Diamond Engagement Ring 5/8 ct tw Round-cut 14K White Gold

GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$2,449.99 
30% off
Was $3,499.99 
Round-Cut Black & White Diamond Engagement Ring 2-1/5 ct tw 14K White Gold
Variations Available

Clearance - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$1,469.99 
30% off
Was $2,099.99 
Now + Forever Oval-Cut Diamond Bypass Engagement Ring 7/8 ct tw 14K Yellow Gold

Online Exclusive

$2,799.99 
30% off
Was $3,999.99 
Neil Lane Tanzanite & Diamond Engagement Ring 5/8 ct tw Round-cut 14K White Gold

GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$2,309.99 
30% off
Was $3,299.99 
Neil Lane Cushion-Cut London Blue Topaz Engagement Ring 1/2 ct tw Diamond 14K White Gold

GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$1,399.99 
30% off
Was $1,999.99 
undefinedundefinedundefined
Now + Forever Diamond Engagement Ring 1/3 ct tw Round-cut 14K Two-Tone Gold

Clearance - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$812.49 
35% off
Was $1,249.99 
Neil Lane Citrine & Diamond Engagement Ring 1/2 ct tw Round-cut 14K Yellow Gold

GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$1,889.99 
30% off
Was $2,699.99 
Neil Lane Emerald-cut Diamond Engagement Ring 1-3/8 ct tw 14K White Gold

Online Exclusive - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$6,299.99 
30% off
Was $8,999.99 
Now + Forever Lab-Grown Diamonds Hexagon & Triangle-Cut Three-Stone Engagement Ring 3-1/3 ct tw 14K Yellow Gold

GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$5,249.99 
30% off
Was $7,499.99 
Now + Forever Diamond Engagement Ring 3/4 ct tw Oval & Round 14K White Gold

Online Exclusive - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$2,029.99 
30% off
Was $2,899.99 
Neil Lane Cushion-cut Citrine Engagement Ring 5/8 ct tw Diamonds 14K White Gold

GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$1,749.99 
30% off
Was $2,499.99 
Neil Lane Cushion-cut Garnet Engagement Ring 1/2 ct tw Diamonds 14K Rose Gold

Clearance - GET IT BY VALENTINE'S DAY

$1,439.99 
40% off
Was $2,399.99 
Showing 42 of 89 products