Up to 50% Off† Mother's Day Specials
A stunning gift for mom, and an even better deal for you.
Personalized Heart Jewelry
Celebrate love with personalized heart jewelry from KAY. From romantic heart-shaped pendants to playful heart earrings to sparkling heart rings, discover personalized heart jewelry to add to your own collection or to gift to someone you love.
items returned.
items returned.
- Price Low to High
- Price High to Low
- Newest Arrivals
- Most popular
items returned.
- Price Low to High
- Price High to Low
- Newest Arrivals
- Most popular
Engravable Three Hearts Paperclip Chain Bracelet Sterling SilverPersonalized ORDER BY 4/28/2026
Personalized ORDER BY 4/28/2026
$179.99
Heart-Shaped White Lab-Created Sapphire & Diamond Promise Ring 1/15 ct tw Sterling SilverPersonalized ORDER BY 4/27/2026
Personalized ORDER BY 4/27/2026
$249.99
Couple's Birthstone Infinity Heart Necklace (2 Stones 2 Lines)New Personalized ORDER BY 4/23/2026
New Personalized ORDER BY 4/23/2026
$156.17
Your Own Fingerprint & Handwriting Heart Necklace 10K Yellow Gold-Plated Sterling Silver 18"New Personalized ORDER BY 5/4/2026
New Personalized ORDER BY 5/4/2026
$249.00
Your Own Handwriting Initial & Heart Mini Tags Necklace 10K Yellow Gold-Plated Sterling Silver 18"New Personalized ORDER BY 5/4/2026
New Personalized ORDER BY 5/4/2026
$259.00
Couple's Engravable Diamond Accent Heart Bracelet 14K Yellow Gold 7.5"Personalized ORDER BY 4/28/2026
Personalized ORDER BY 4/28/2026
$999.99
Couple's Heart-Shaped Birthstone Infinity Ring (2 Stones and Lines)Personalized ORDER BY 4/23/2026
Personalized ORDER BY 4/23/2026
$154.56
Round Birthstone and White Lab-Created Sapphire Heart Charm Initial Necklace (1 Stone and 1 Initial)Personalized ORDER BY 4/23/2026
Personalized ORDER BY 4/23/2026
$162.83
Couple's Heart-Shaped Birthstone Infinity Necklace (2 Stones and Lines)Personalized ORDER BY 4/23/2026
Personalized ORDER BY 4/23/2026
$170.05
Couple's Diamond Accent Decorative Lock Paperclip Chain Necklace Sterling Silver 18"Personalized ORDER BY 4/28/2026
Personalized ORDER BY 4/28/2026
$349.99
Initials and Birthstone Heart Paperclip Chain Necklace (2 Initials and 1 Stone)Personalized ORDER BY 4/23/2026
Personalized ORDER BY 4/23/2026
$175.89
Couple's Circle Color Heart Stone Necklace (2 Stones and Lines)Personalized ORDER BY 4/23/2026
Personalized ORDER BY 4/23/2026
$154.20
Family & Mother's Birthstone Heart Necklace (2-4 Stones and Lines)Personalized ORDER BY 4/23/2026
Personalized ORDER BY 4/23/2026
$163.62
Mother's Heart-Shaped Family Birthstone Drop Necklace (1-3 Stones and 2-3 Lines)Personalized ORDER BY 4/23/2026
Personalized ORDER BY 4/23/2026
$125.52
Mother's Heart-Shaped Family Birthstone Swirl Necklace (1-4 Stones and Lines)Personalized ORDER BY 4/23/2026
Personalized ORDER BY 4/23/2026
$133.89
Couple's Heart-Shaped Birthstone Infinity Necklace (2 Stones and Lines)Personalized ORDER BY 4/23/2026
Personalized ORDER BY 4/23/2026
$149.50
Birthstone Family & Mother's Heart Vertical Bar Necklace (1-4 Stones and Lines)Personalized ORDER BY 4/23/2026
Personalized ORDER BY 4/23/2026
$150.08
Family & Mother's Birthstone Heart Necklace 18" (2-4 Stones and Lines)Personalized ORDER BY 4/23/2026
Personalized ORDER BY 4/23/2026
$170.33
Mother's Heart-Shaped Family Swirl Birthstone Ring (2-4 Stones and Lines)Personalized ORDER BY 4/23/2026
Personalized ORDER BY 4/23/2026
$162.97
Family Birthstone Mother and Child Ring (2-6 Stones and 2 Lines)Personalized ORDER BY 4/23/2026
Personalized ORDER BY 4/23/2026
$139.70
Couple's Heart-Shaped Birthstone Necklace (2 Stones and Lines)Personalized ORDER BY 4/23/2026
Personalized ORDER BY 4/23/2026
$159.89
Mother's Heart-Shaped Family Birthstone Ring (1-3 Stones and 2 Lines)Personalized ORDER BY 4/23/2026
Personalized ORDER BY 4/23/2026
$141.22
Mother's Family Heart-Shaped Birthstone Necklace (2-7 Stones)Personalized ORDER BY 4/23/2026
Personalized ORDER BY 4/23/2026
$143.89
Mother's Heart-Shaped Family Birthstone Ring (2-6 Stones and Lines)Personalized ORDER BY 4/23/2026
Personalized ORDER BY 4/23/2026
$131.08
Mother's Family Birthstone & Diamond Heart Necklace (1-7 Stones)Personalized ORDER BY 4/23/2026
Personalized ORDER BY 4/23/2026
$123.64
Birthstone Couple's Heart Adjustable Bracelet (2 Stones and Lines)Personalized ORDER BY 4/23/2026
Personalized ORDER BY 4/23/2026
$172.99
Couple's Birthstone Double Heart Necklace 1/20 ct tw Diamonds (2 Stones and Lines)Personalized ORDER BY 4/23/2026
Personalized ORDER BY 4/23/2026
$184.11
Showing 41 of 445 products