Unique Engagement Rings

Bold engagement rings are different from your typical engagement ring, with unique shapes, gemstones and more you'll find the perfect style ring your partner will love. Wear the story of your love with engagement rings from Kay. Say yes to Kay's collection of unique engagement rings in stunning styles.

107 Results items returned.

Sort By:

Price Low to High
Price High to Low
Newest Arrivals
Most popular

Sort By:

Filter By

Get It Fast

Quick Ship - Ships in 1-3 Business Days (11) Items Available

Store Pickup at

Select Store

Same Day Delivery from Select Store

Offers & Discounts

10% & up (40) Items Available

20% & up (40) Items Available

30% & up (40) Items Available

40% & up (36) Items Available

50% & up (17) Items Available

Stone Shape

Pear (25) Items Available

Round (20) Items Available

Oval (19) Items Available

Cushion (10) Items Available

Princess-Cut (8) Items Available

Stone Type

Diamond (92) Items Available

Lab-Grown Diamond (3) Items Available

Amethyst (3) Items Available

Aquamarine (7) Items Available

Citrine (3) Items Available

Stone Color

Black (16) Items Available

Blue (18) Items Available

Green (6) Items Available

Peach (14) Items Available

Pink (2) Items Available

Center Stone Total Weight

Under 1/4 Ctw (4) Items Available

1/4 Ctw - Under 1/2 Ctw (6) Items Available

1/2 Ctw - Under 1 Ctw (17) Items Available

1 Ctw - Under 2 Ctw (6) Items Available

2 Ctw - Under 3 Ctw (2) Items Available

Carat Range

Under 1/4 Ctw (3) Items Available

1/4 Ctw - Under 1/2 Ctw (11) Items Available

1/2 Ctw - Under 1 Ctw (52) Items Available

1 Ctw - Under 3 Ctw (33) Items Available

3 Ctw - Under 5 Ctw (8) Items Available

Style

2-Stone (3) Items Available

3-Stone (6) Items Available

Bezel (2) Items Available

Channel (7) Items Available

Chevron (4) Items Available

Price

$501-$1,000 (3) Items Available

$1,001-$2,500 (54) Items Available

$2,501-$5,000 (42) Items Available

$5,001-$9,999 (7) Items Available

$10,000 and above (1) Items Available

$ min

$ max

Metal Color

White (80) Items Available

Rose (32) Items Available

Yellow (10) Items Available

Two-Tone (4) Items Available

Metal Type

Gold (107) Items Available

Platinum (2) Items Available

Gender

WOMEN (107) Items Available

Jewelry Type

Ring (103) Items Available

Coordinates (4) Items Available

Ring Style

Bridal Set (8) Items Available

Engagement Ring (95) Items Available

Ring Size

4.0 (1) Items Available

4.5 (1) Items Available

4.75 (1) Items Available

5.0 (35) Items Available

5.25 (26) Items Available

107 Results items returned.

Sort By:

Price Low to High
Price High to Low
Newest Arrivals
Most popular

Sort By:

Unique Engagement Rings

Filter By

Get It Fast

Offers & Discounts

Stone Shape

Stone Type

Stone Color

Center Stone Total Weight

Carat Range

Style

Price

Metal Color

Metal Type

Gender

Jewelry Type

Ring Style

Ring Size

Toi et Moi Pear-Shaped & Oval-Cut Lab-Grown Diamond Engagement ring 2 ct tw in 14K Yellow GoldClearance

Toi et Moi Emerald-Cut & Pear-Shaped Lab-Grown diamond Engagement Ring 4-1/4 ct tw 14K Rose GoldOnline Exclusive

Neil Lane Diamond Engagement Ring 1-1/2 ct tw 14K White GoldClearance

Previously Owned Diamond Engagement Ring 7/8 ct tw Marquise & Round 14K White GoldPreviously Owned Lovingly Restored

Previously Owned THE LEO First Light Diamond Engagement Ring 1 ct tw Oval & Round-cut 14K White GoldPreviously Owned Lovingly Restored

Neil Lane Morganite Engagement Ring 3/4 ct tw Pear & Round-cut 14K White GoldOnline Exclusive

Now + Forever Aquamarine & Lab-Created Sapphire Engagement Ring Round-cut 14K White GoldOnline Exclusive

Neil Lane Morganite & Diamond Engagement Ring 1/3 ct tw Round-cut 14K Rose GoldClearance

Neil Lane Pear-Shaped Diamond Engagement Ring 1-7/8 ct tw 14K White GoldClearance

Previously Owned Multi-Stone Diamond Engagment Ring 1-1/2 ct tw Round-cut 14K White GoldPreviously Owned Lovingly Restored

Neil Lane Rhodolite Garnet Engagement Ring 1/2 ct tw Diamonds 14K Rose GoldClearance

Toi et Moi Emerald-Cut & Pear-Shaped Lab-Grown diamond Engagement ring 4-1/4 ct tw 14K White GoldClearance

Neil Lane Emerald-cut Diamond Engagement Ring 1-3/8 ct tw 14K White GoldOnline Exclusive

Now + Forever Diamond Engagement Ring 1/4 ct tw Round-cut 10K Yellow GoldOnline Exclusive

Neil Lane Cushion-cut Garnet Engagement Ring 1/2 ct tw Diamonds 14K Rose GoldClearance

Now + Forever Black & White Diamond Bridal Set 3/4 ct tw Round-cut 10K White GoldOnline Exclusive

Neil Lane Engagement Ring 3/4 ct tw Diamonds 14K White GoldOnline Exclusive

Neil Lane Rhodolite Garnet & Diamond Engagement Ring 1/2 ct tw Round-cut 14K White GoldClearance

Neil Lane Aquamarine & Diamond Engagement Ring 1/2 ct tw Round-cut 14K White GoldClearance

Now + Forever Round-Cut Diamond Engagement Ring 1 ct tw 14K White GoldOnline Exclusive

Neil Lane Morganite Engagement Ring 3/4 ct tw Diamonds 14K Rose GoldClearance

Neil Lane Aquamarine & Diamond Engagement Ring 5/8 ct tw Round-cut 14K White GoldClearance

Now + Forever Diamond Engagement Ring 1-3/4 ct tw Round-cut 14K White GoldOnline Exclusive

Now + Forever Round-Cut Black & White Diamond Engagement Ring 2-1/5 ct tw 14K White GoldClearance

Now + Forever Multi-Diamond Center Bridal Set 1-1/2 ct tw Round & Baguette-cut 10K White GoldOnline Exclusive

Now + Forever Oval Aquamarine Engagement Ring 1/3 ct tw Diamonds 14K White GoldClearance

Now + Forever Oval-Cut Diamond Bypass Engagement Ring 7/8 ct tw 14K Yellow GoldOnline Exclusive

Neil Lane Morganite Engagement Ring 3/8 ct tw Diamonds 14K GoldClearance

Previously Owned Black & White Diamond Engagement Ring 1 ct tw 10K Rose Gold Size 7Previously Owned Lovingly Restored

CUSTOMER SERVICES

PAYMENTS & REWARDS

STORES & SERVICES

ABOUT US

QUICK LINKS & EDUCATION

FOLLOW US

Toi et Moi Pear-Shaped & Oval-Cut Lab-Grown Diamond Engagement ring 2 ct tw in 14K Yellow Gold
Clearance

Toi et Moi Emerald-Cut & Pear-Shaped Lab-Grown diamond Engagement Ring 4-1/4 ct tw 14K Rose Gold
Online Exclusive

Neil Lane Diamond Engagement Ring 1-1/2 ct tw 14K White Gold
Clearance

Previously Owned Diamond Engagement Ring 7/8 ct tw Marquise & Round 14K White Gold
Previously Owned Lovingly Restored

Previously Owned THE LEO First Light Diamond Engagement Ring 1 ct tw Oval & Round-cut 14K White Gold
Previously Owned Lovingly Restored

Neil Lane Morganite Engagement Ring 3/4 ct tw Pear & Round-cut 14K White Gold
Online Exclusive

Now + Forever Aquamarine & Lab-Created Sapphire Engagement Ring Round-cut 14K White Gold
Online Exclusive

Neil Lane Morganite & Diamond Engagement Ring 1/3 ct tw Round-cut 14K Rose Gold
Clearance

Neil Lane Pear-Shaped Diamond Engagement Ring 1-7/8 ct tw 14K White Gold
Clearance

Previously Owned Multi-Stone Diamond Engagment Ring 1-1/2 ct tw Round-cut 14K White Gold
Previously Owned Lovingly Restored

Neil Lane Rhodolite Garnet Engagement Ring 1/2 ct tw Diamonds 14K Rose Gold
Clearance

Toi et Moi Emerald-Cut & Pear-Shaped Lab-Grown diamond Engagement ring 4-1/4 ct tw 14K White Gold
Clearance

Neil Lane Emerald-cut Diamond Engagement Ring 1-3/8 ct tw 14K White Gold
Online Exclusive

Now + Forever Diamond Engagement Ring 1/4 ct tw Round-cut 10K Yellow Gold
Online Exclusive

Neil Lane Cushion-cut Garnet Engagement Ring 1/2 ct tw Diamonds 14K Rose Gold
Clearance

Now + Forever Black & White Diamond Bridal Set 3/4 ct tw Round-cut 10K White Gold
Online Exclusive

Neil Lane Engagement Ring 3/4 ct tw Diamonds 14K White Gold
Online Exclusive

Neil Lane Rhodolite Garnet & Diamond Engagement Ring 1/2 ct tw Round-cut 14K White Gold
Clearance

Neil Lane Aquamarine & Diamond Engagement Ring 1/2 ct tw Round-cut 14K White Gold
Clearance

Now + Forever Round-Cut Diamond Engagement Ring 1 ct tw 14K White Gold
Online Exclusive

Neil Lane Morganite Engagement Ring 3/4 ct tw Diamonds 14K Rose Gold
Clearance

Neil Lane Aquamarine & Diamond Engagement Ring 5/8 ct tw Round-cut 14K White Gold
Clearance

Now + Forever Diamond Engagement Ring 1-3/4 ct tw Round-cut 14K White Gold
Online Exclusive

Now + Forever Round-Cut Black & White Diamond Engagement Ring 2-1/5 ct tw 14K White Gold
Clearance

Now + Forever Multi-Diamond Center Bridal Set 1-1/2 ct tw Round & Baguette-cut 10K White Gold
Online Exclusive

Now + Forever Oval Aquamarine Engagement Ring 1/3 ct tw Diamonds 14K White Gold
Clearance

Now + Forever Oval-Cut Diamond Bypass Engagement Ring 7/8 ct tw 14K Yellow Gold
Online Exclusive

Neil Lane Morganite Engagement Ring 3/8 ct tw Diamonds 14K Gold
Clearance

Previously Owned Black & White Diamond Engagement Ring 1 ct tw 10K Rose Gold Size 7
Previously Owned Lovingly Restored