Previously Owned Jewelry

Engagement Rings

+10% in Bag

Previously Owned Diamond Solitaire Charm 1/10 ct tw Round-cut 14K White Gold (J/I3)

Previously Owned Diamond Solitaire Charm 1/10 ct tw Round-cut 14K White Gold (J/I3)

Previously Owned

+10% in Bag

Previously Owned Princess-Cut Quad Diamond Halo Charm 1/4 ct tw 10K White Gold

Previously Owned Princess-Cut Quad Diamond Halo Charm 1/4 ct tw 10K White Gold

Previously Owned

+10% in Bag

Previously Owned KAY Lab-Grown Diamonds Cross Charm 1/2 ct tw 14K White Gold

Previously Owned KAY Lab-Grown Diamonds Cross Charm 1/2 ct tw 14K White Gold

Previously Owned

Previously Owned Neil Lane Princess-Cut Diamond Halo Bridal Set 2-1/5 ct tw 14K White Gold Size 5.5

Previously Owned Neil Lane Princess-Cut Diamond Halo Bridal Set 2-1/5 ct tw 14K White Gold Size 5.5

Previously Owned

+10% in Bag

Previously Owned Cartouche Charm 10K Yellow Gold

Previously Owned Cartouche Charm 10K Yellow Gold

Previously Owned

+10% in Bag

Previously Owned Ring 1 ct tw Diamonds 14K Yellow Gold

Previously Owned Ring 1 ct tw Diamonds 14K Yellow Gold

Previously Owned

+10% in Bag

Previously Owned KAY Lab-Grown Diamonds Oval-Cut Halo Charm 1/2 ct tw 10K Yellow Gold

Previously Owned KAY Lab-Grown Diamonds Oval-Cut Halo Charm 1/2 ct tw 10K Yellow Gold

Previously Owned

+10% in Bag

Previously Owned Diamond Bypass Multi-Row Ring 1 ct tw 10K White Gold

Previously Owned Diamond Bypass Multi-Row Ring 1 ct tw 10K White Gold

Previously Owned

+10% in Bag

Previously Owned Radiant Reflections Diamond Solitaire Charm 1/10 ct tw 10K Yellow Gold (J/I3)

Previously Owned Radiant Reflections Diamond Solitaire Charm 1/10 ct tw 10K Yellow Gold (J/I3)

Previously Owned

+10% in Bag

Previously Owned Lab-Grown Diamonds Princess-Cut Solitaire Engagement Ring 1-1/2 ct tw 14K White Gold (F/SI2)

Previously Owned Lab-Grown Diamonds Princess-Cut Solitaire Engagement Ring 1-1/2 ct tw 14K White Gold (F/SI2)

Previously Owned

Previously Owned COACH Cary Women's Watch 14503832

Previously Owned COACH Cary Women's Watch 14503832

Previously Owned

+10% in Bag

Previously Owned KAY Lab-Grown Diamonds Multi-Stone Teardrop Charm 1/2 ct tw 10K Yellow Gold

Previously Owned KAY Lab-Grown Diamonds Multi-Stone Teardrop Charm 1/2 ct tw 10K Yellow Gold

Previously Owned

+10% in Bag

Previously Owned Diamond Cross Charm 1/4 ct tw Round-Cut 10K White Gold

Previously Owned Diamond Cross Charm 1/4 ct tw Round-Cut 10K White Gold

Previously Owned

+10% in Bag

Previously Owned Neil Lane Diamond Ring 2-1/6 ct tw Cushion & Round-cut 14K Gold

Previously Owned Neil Lane Diamond Ring 2-1/6 ct tw Cushion & Round-cut 14K Gold

Previously Owned

Previously Owned THE LEO Ideal Cut Diamond Engagement Ring 1-1/3 ct tw 14K White Gold

Previously Owned THE LEO Ideal Cut Diamond Engagement Ring 1-1/3 ct tw 14K White Gold

Previously Owned

+10% in Bag

Previously Owned Memories Moments Magic Oval-Cut Lab-Grown Diamond Three-Stone Engagement Ring 3-1/2 ct tw 14K Yellow Gold

Previously Owned Memories Moments Magic Oval-Cut Lab-Grown Diamond Three-Stone Engagement Ring 3-1/2 ct tw 14K Yellow Gold

Previously Owned

+10% in Bag

Previously Owned Diamond Charm 1/2 ct tw Round-cut 10K White Gold

Previously Owned Diamond Charm 1/2 ct tw Round-cut 10K White Gold

Previously Owned

+10% in Bag

Previously Owned Lab-Grown Diamonds Round-Cut Solitaire Engagement Ring 1-1/2 ct tw 14K White Gold (F/SI2)

Previously Owned Lab-Grown Diamonds Round-Cut Solitaire Engagement Ring 1-1/2 ct tw 14K White Gold (F/SI2)

Previously Owned

+10% in Bag

Previously Owned Neil Lane Round-Cut Diamond Crossover Anniversary Band 1/3 ct tw 14K Yellow Gold

Previously Owned Neil Lane Round-Cut Diamond Crossover Anniversary Band 1/3 ct tw 14K Yellow Gold

Previously Owned

Previously Owned Bulova Racer Chronograph Men's Watch 98B432

Previously Owned Bulova Racer Chronograph Men's Watch 98B432

Previously Owned

+10% in Bag

Previously Owned Unstoppable Love Diamond Charm 1/10 ct tw Sterling Silver

Previously Owned Unstoppable Love Diamond Charm 1/10 ct tw Sterling Silver

Previously Owned

+10% in Bag

Previously Owned Round-Cut Diamond Anniversary Band 1/2 ct tw 14K Yellow Gold

Previously Owned Round-Cut Diamond Anniversary Band 1/2 ct tw 14K Yellow Gold

Previously Owned

+10% in Bag

Previously Owned Diamond Circle Charm 1/4 ct tw Round-cut 10K White Gold

Previously Owned Diamond Circle Charm 1/4 ct tw Round-cut 10K White Gold

Previously Owned

+10% in Bag

Previously Owned Men's Diamond Bracelet 1 ct tw Sterling Silver 8.5"

Previously Owned Men's Diamond Bracelet 1 ct tw Sterling Silver 8.5"

Previously Owned

+10% in Bag

Previously Owned KAY Lab-Grown Diamonds Round-Cut Solitaire Twist Teardrop Charm 1/3 ct tw Sterling Silver (I/SI2)

Previously Owned KAY Lab-Grown Diamonds Round-Cut Solitaire Twist Teardrop Charm 1/3 ct tw Sterling Silver (I/SI2)

Previously Owned

+10% in Bag

Previously Owned Diamond Accent Tilted Hearts Charm 10K Rose Gold

Previously Owned Diamond Accent Tilted Hearts Charm 10K Rose Gold

Previously Owned

Previously Owned Citizen Women's Watch POV Drive EM0233-51A

Previously Owned Citizen Women's Watch POV Drive EM0233-51A

Previously Owned

+10% in Bag

Previously Owned Unstoppable Love Diamond Heart Charm 1/3 ct tw 10K Yellow Gold

Previously Owned Unstoppable Love Diamond Heart Charm 1/3 ct tw 10K Yellow Gold

Previously Owned

+10% in Bag

Previously Owned Princess-Cut Three-Stone Black & White Diamond Bridal Set 1-1/5 ct tw 10K & 14K White Gold Size 5.25

Previously Owned Princess-Cut Three-Stone Black & White Diamond Bridal Set 1-1/5 ct tw 10K & 14K White Gold Size 5.25

Previously Owned

+10% in Bag

Previously Owned Diamond Cross Charm 1/2 ct tw Round-cut 10K Yellow Gold

Previously Owned Diamond Cross Charm 1/2 ct tw Round-cut 10K Yellow Gold

Previously Owned

+10% in Bag

Previously Owned KAY Lab-Grown Diamonds Heart Charm 1 ct tw 14K White Gold

Previously Owned KAY Lab-Grown Diamonds Heart Charm 1 ct tw 14K White Gold

Previously Owned

+10% in Bag

Previously Owned KAY Lab-Grown Diamonds Round-cut Solitaire Stud Earrings 1/2 ct tw 14K Yellow Gold (F/SI2)

Previously Owned KAY Lab-Grown Diamonds Round-cut Solitaire Stud Earrings 1/2 ct tw 14K Yellow Gold (F/SI2)

Previously Owned

Previously Owned Lab-Grown Diamond Graduated Inside-Out Hoop Earrings 2 ct tw 10K White Gold

Previously Owned Lab-Grown Diamond Graduated Inside-Out Hoop Earrings 2 ct tw 10K White Gold

Previously Owned

+10% in Bag

Previously Owned KAY Lab-Grown Diamonds Circle Halo Charm 1/2 ct tw 10K White Gold

Previously Owned KAY Lab-Grown Diamonds Circle Halo Charm 1/2 ct tw 10K White Gold

Previously Owned

+10% in Bag

Previously Owned Diamond Enhancer Ring 1/8 ct tw Round-cut 14K White Gold

Previously Owned Diamond Enhancer Ring 1/8 ct tw Round-cut 14K White Gold

Previously Owned

Previously Owned Certified Diamond Engagement Ring 1-1/5 ct tw 14K White Gold Size 7

Previously Owned Certified Diamond Engagement Ring 1-1/5 ct tw 14K White Gold Size 7

Previously Owned

+10% in Bag

Previously Owned Neil Lane Baguette-Cut Rhodolite Garnet & Round-Cut Diamond Anniversary Ring 1/8 14K Rose Gold

Previously Owned Neil Lane Baguette-Cut Rhodolite Garnet & Round-Cut Diamond Anniversary Ring 1/8 14K Rose Gold

Previously Owned

+10% in Bag

Previously Owned Unstoppable Love Diamond Double Cushion Frame Charm 1/4 ct tw 10K Yellow Gold

Previously Owned Unstoppable Love Diamond Double Cushion Frame Charm 1/4 ct tw 10K Yellow Gold

Previously Owned

+10% in Bag

Previously Owned THE LEO First Light Diamond Princess & Round-Cut Anniversary Ring 1 ct tw 14K White Gold

Previously Owned THE LEO First Light Diamond Princess & Round-Cut Anniversary Ring 1 ct tw 14K White Gold

Previously Owned

+10% in Bag

Previously Owned Memories Moments Magic KAY Lab-Grown Diamonds Graduated Three-Stone Charm 3/4 ct tw 14K White Gold

Previously Owned Memories Moments Magic KAY Lab-Grown Diamonds Graduated Three-Stone Charm 3/4 ct tw 14K White Gold

Previously Owned

Showing 40 of 1303 products

Find previously owned jewelry at affordable prices when you shop at KAY. Still in impeccable condition, you can purchase pre-owned engagement rings, pre-owned diamond rings, and more without the strain on your bank account. Explore our selection online or at a KAY near you to find the perfect piece at the perfect price.